Interpreting Contrary to Pancasila Under Article 188 (1) of the Indonesian Criminal Code and Its Implication Towards Freedom of Expressions
Zhavia Lysandra Hakim, Devita Kartika Putri, S.H, LL.M
2026 | Skripsi | ILMU HUKUM
Penelitian ini mengkaji interpretasi frasa bertentangan dengan pancasila dalam Pasal 188 (1) KUHP serta implikasinya terhadap kebebasan berekspresi. Ketentuan tersebut mengkriminalisasi penyebaran atau pengembangan ajaran yang dianggap bertentangan dengan pancasila; namun, ketiadaan batas interpretasi yang jelas menimbulkan persoalan terkait kepastian hukum dan potensi perluasan hukum pidana secara berlebihan ke dalam ranah ekspresi ideologis dan perbedaan pendapat politik.
Dengan menggunakan metode penelitian yuridis normatif, penelitian ini menerapkan pendekatan perundang-undangan, pendekatan konseptual, pendekatan historis, dan pendekatan perbandingan. Analisis dilakukan melalui metode penafsiran gramatikal, sistematis, dan teleologis terhadap frasa bertentangan dengan pancasila dalam pasal 188 (1) KUHP yang didukung dengan wawancara terhadap para ahli hukum sebagai data pendukung untuk memperkaya analisis normatif.
Penelitian ini juga mengkaji apakah ketentuan tersebut memenuhi prinsip legalitas, kebutuhan, dan proporsionalitas yang berlaku terhadap pembatasan ekspresi politik dan ideologis. Penelitain ini menemukan bahwa rumusan Pasal 188 (1) yang bersifat tidak pasti berisiko mencakup bentuk-bentuk ekspresi yang pada dasarnya hanya merupakan perbedaan pandangan ideologis, dan bukan ancaman nyata terhadap tatanan konstitusional.
This thesis examines the interpretation of the phrase contrary to pancasila under Article 188 (1) of the KUHP and its implication towards freedom of expressions. The provision criminalises the dissemination or development of teachings deemed contrary to Pancasila; however, the absence of clear interpretive limits give rise to concerns regarding legal certainty and the potential overreach of criminal law into the realm of ideological expression and political dissent.
Employing a normative juridical methodology, this research analyses Article 188 (1) of the KUHP through statutory, conceptual, historical and comparative approaches, using grammatical, systematic, historical and teleological methods of legal interpretations. To enrich and validate the normative analysis, the research is complemented by semi-structured interviews with legal scholars and practitioners. The thesis further examines whether the provision satisfies the requirements of legality, necessity, and proportionality applicable to restrictions on political and ideological expressions.
This thesis finds that the indeterminate formulation of Article 188 (1) risks encompassing forms of expressions that amount merely to ideological dissagreement rather than concrete threats to the constitutional order. In the absence of sufficiently precise limiting principles, the provision creates the potential for arbitrary enforcement and excessive restrictions of political expressions.
Accordingly, the thesis argues that Article 188 (1) of the KUHP should be interpreted restrictively so as to apply only to intentional acts of collective anti-constitutional mobilisation directed toward undermining or replacing the constitutional system. Failing such a restrictive interpretation, the continued inclusion of the provision within the KUHP warrants reconsideration. This research in any form does not contest ideological offence, but recommends a law that is restrictive.
Kata Kunci : Pancasila, legality, freedom of expressions, ideology, Article 188 (1) KUHP, Indonesia