Pelindungan Hukum Pemilik Tanah dalam Perjanjian Sewa Menyewa dengan PT Indo Bhali Makmurjaya yang Objeknya Masuk dalam Boedel Pailit Penyewa
LAILY NUR AISAH, Prof. Dr. Ari Hernawan, S.H., M.Hum.
2026 | Tesis | S2 Magister Kenotariatan
A lessee was declared bankrupt before the expiration of the lease term, whereas the lease agreement stipulated that the buildings erected on the leased land would become the property of the landowner upon the expiry of the lease. This situation gives rise to legal uncertainty concerning the legal protection afforded to the landowner and the legal status of the buildings that form part of the lessee's bankruptcy estate. This research aims to analyze the legal protection afforded to the landowner under a land lease agreement where the leasehold interest forms part of the lessee's bankruptcy estate, and to examine, in light of the horizontal separation principle, the legal status of buildings erected by the lessee and contractually agreed to vest in the landowner upon the expiration of the lease term when the lessee is declared bankrupt.
This research employs normative legal research. The findings demonstrate that the legal protection afforded to the landowner consists of both preventive and repressive legal protection derived from internal and external sources. Internal preventive protection is embodied in the contractual clauses agreed upon by the parties, whereas external preventive protection is provided by the Indonesian Civil Code (Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Perdata) and Law Number 37 of 2004 on Bankruptcy and Suspension of Debt Payment Obligations. However, the lease agreement does not regulate the legal consequences arising from the lessee's bankruptcy, resulting in the absence of internal repressive legal protection. Consequently, the landowner's legal protection depends on external legal remedies in the form of Other Civil Actions (Gugatan Lain-Lain) and limitations on the curator's authority as stipulated in the lease agreement.
This research further concludes that, under the horizontal separation principle, the buildings remain the property of the lessee throughout the lease term. Nevertheless, pursuant to the lease agreement, ownership of the buildings is transferred to the landowner upon the expiration of the lease as a conditional obligation subject to a suspensive condition. Accordingly, the curator is authorized only to administer and liquidate the bankruptcy estate within the limits of the debtor's rights and may not prejudice the landowner's contractual rights as agreed by the parties.
Kata Kunci : pelindungan hukum, sewa menyewa tanah, kepailitan, boedel pailit