Prinsip Ekonomi Sirkular dan Rendah Karbon pada Renovasi Bangunan Hotel Uma Tilu
Alifia Niza Salafy, Dr. Yani Rahmawati, S.T., M.T.
2026 | Tesis | S2 Teknik Arsitektur
Sektor bangunan menyumbang sekitar 30 hingga 39 persen emisi gas rumah kaca global, dan renovasi bangunan komersial seperti hotel sering kali masih dilakukan dengan pendekatan business as usual yang mengabaikan dampak embodied carbon. Kondisi ini terjadi pada renovasi Hotel Uma Tilu di Yogyakarta, yang dilakukan sebagai bagian dari pergantian nama dan kepemilikan tanpa mempertimbangkan besaran embodied carbon dari proses pembongkaran dan penggantian material. Penelitian ini bertujuan mengevaluasi penerapan prinsip ekonomi sirkular pada renovasi Hotel Uma Tilu melalui perbandingan embodied carbon antara pendekatan konvensional dan skenario ekonomi sirkular, serta merumuskan skenario penerapannya dalam proses desain menggunakan pendekatan SWOT-AHP. Penelitian menggunakan metode combined skenarios yang menggabungkan perhitungan embodied carbon berbasis Life Cycle Assessment mengacu pada standar EN 15978, wawancara dan kuesioner dengan empat pakar melalui teknik expert sampling untuk mencari gap penerapan skenario ekonomi sirkular pada konteks bangunan hotel di Indonesia, serta analisis SWOT-AHP untuk menentukan prioritas penerapannya. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa skenario intensive use mampu menurunkan embodied carbon sebesar 31,6 persen dibanding kondisi konvensional, sedangkan skenario gabungan yang mengombinasikan material rendah karbon, peningkatan recycling rate dan advanced prefabrocation mampu menurunkan embodied carbon hingga 61,9 persen. Analisis SWOT-AHP menempatkan penerapan ST, yaitu penyusunan panduan desain renovasi berbasis data kuantitatif reduksi embodied carbon, sebagai prioritas utama dengan bobot 35,2 persen. Penerapan ini diwujudkan dalam bentuk tabel pembanding embodied carbon untuk lima elemen bangunan dengan volume material terbesar, yaitu struktur, fasad, atap, bukaan dan finishing yang dapat digunakan arsitek pada tahap skematik desain untuk membandingkan opsi mempertahankan atau mengganti elemen eksisting. Penelitian ini diharapkan dapat menjadi acuan praktis bagi arsitek dan pengelola hotel dalam merancang renovasi yang lebih rendah karbon.
The building sector accounts for approximately 30–39% of global greenhouse gas emissions, while the renovation of commercial buildings, such as hotels, is often carried out using a business-as-usual approach that overlooks embodied carbon impacts. This condition was observed in the renovation of the Uma Tilu Hotel in Yogyakarta, which was undertaken as part of a change in ownership and rebranding without considering the embodied carbon associated with material demolition and replacement. This study aims to evaluate the application of circular economy principles in the renovation of the Uma Tilu Hotel by comparing the embodied carbon of a conventional renovation approach with circular economy scenarios, as well as to formulate implementation strategies for the design process using the SWOT–AHP approach. The study employed a combined-scenarios method integrating embodied carbon assessment based on the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology in accordance with EN 15978, expert interviews and questionnaires involving four specialists selected through expert sampling to validate the circular economy scenarios, and SWOT–AHP analysis to determine implementation priorities. The results indicate that the intensive use scenario reduced embodied carbon by 31,6% compared with the conventional approach, while the combined scenario, incorporating low-carbon materials, increased recycling rates, and advanced prefabrication, achieved an embodied carbon reduction of up to 47,96%. SWOT–AHP analysis identified the ST strategy, developing renovation design guidelines based on quantitative embodied carbon reduction data, as the highest priority, with a weight of 35.2%. This strategy was implemented in the form of a comparative embodied carbon table covering the five building elements with the largest material volumes, namely the structural system, façade, roof, openings, and finishes. The table is intended to assist architects during the schematic design stage in comparing alternatives for retaining or replacing existing building elements. This study is expected to serve as a practical reference for architects and hotel managers in designing lower-carbon renovation projects.
Kata Kunci : ekonomi sirkular, embodied carbon, renovasi hotel, SWOT-AHP