Studi Perbandingan Kinerja Algoritma Maximum Power Point Tracking Pada Sistem Fotovoltaik Menggunakan Classical, Intelligent, dan Optimization-Based Methods
Risma Indah Putriani, Dr. Ir. Fahmizal, S.T., M.Sc., IPM., ASEAN Eng.
2026 | Tugas Akhir | D4 TEKNOLOGI REKAYASA ELEKTRO
Kinerja sistem pembangkit listrik tenaga surya (PLTS) sangat dipengaruhi oleh fluktuasi iradiasi matahari, perubahan suhu, dan variasi beban yang menyebabkan daya keluaran panel surya tidak selalu berada pada kondisi optimal. Teknik Maximum Power Point Tracking (MPPT) dapat digunakan sebagai sistem kendali untuk melacak dan mempertahankan titik daya maksimum Maximum Power Point / MPP pada berbagai kondisi operasional. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk membandingkan kinerja sistem tanpa MPPT dengan tiga algoritma MPPT, yaitu Incremental Conductance(INC), Fuzzy Logic Controller (FLC), dan Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO). Simulasi dilakukan menggunakan perangkat lunak MATLAB/Simulink R2021a dengan pemodelan modul panel surya Risen Energy RSM132-6-350M yang dihubungkan dengan \textit{DC-DC buck converter}. Sebagai analisis awal, pengujian pada kondisi Standard Test Condition (STC) menunjukkan keempat sistem mencapai titik operasi yang berdekatan dengan MPP (selisih 0,1), dengan FLC unggul dalam kecepatan tracking (0,2 s) dan PSO unggul dalam kedekatan terhadap datasheet panel. Pengujian lanjutan dilakukan pada tiga skenario, yaitu variasi iradiasi (200--1000 W/m2), variasi suhu (15--55~\circC), dan variasi beban (0,8--1,6431~\Omega), dengan parameter evaluasi berupa daya panel surya Ppv, daya keluaran sistem (Pout), dan efisiensi tracking MPPT MPPT. Hasil simulasi menunjukkan bahwa pada variasi iradiasi, FLC mempertahankan efisiensi \textit{tracking} tertinggi (99,48%) dibanding PSO (80,31\%) dan IC (78,27\%). Pada variasi suhu, ketiga algoritma menunjukkan performa relatif setara, dengan efisiensi rata-rata IC 100%, FLC 99,87%, dan PSO 97,18%. Pada variasi beban, FLC menunjukkan kestabilan daya panel terbaik pada rentang 350,1--350,6~W, sedangkan PSO menghasilkan daya keluaran \textit{buck converter} tertinggi sebesar 344,50~W pada kondisi beban nominal. Berdasarkan analisis menyeluruh, algoritma FLC menunjukkan performa paling konsisten di antara ketiga algoritma, sehingga direkomendasikan sebagai algoritma MPPT yang paling adaptif terhadap perubahan kondisi lingkungan yang fluktuatif.
The performance of photovoltaic (PV) power generation systems is highly influenced by fluctuations in solar irradiance, temperature variations, and load changes, which cause the output power of solar panels to deviate from their optimal operating conditions. Maximum Power Point Tracking (MPPT) techniques can be employed as control systems to track and maintain the Maximum Power Point (MPP) under various operating conditions. This study aims to compare the performance of a system without MPPT and three MPPT algorithms, namely Incremental Conductance (INC), Fuzzy Logic Controller (FLC), and Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO). Simulations were conducted using MATLAB/Simulink R2021a with a model of the Risen Energy RSM132-6-350M photovoltaic module connected to a DC-DC buck converter. As a preliminary analysis, testing under Standard Test Conditions (STC) showed that all four systems operated close to the MPP (with a difference of 0.1), where FLC demonstrated the fastest tracking speed (0.2 s), while PSO exhibited the closest performance to the panel datasheet specifications. Further evaluations were carried out under three test scenarios: irradiance variations (200–1000 W/m²), temperature variations (15–55 °C), and load variations (0.8–1.6431 ?). The performance parameters evaluated included photovoltaic power (Ppv), system output power (Pout), and MPPT tracking efficiency. The simulation results indicate that, under irradiance variations, FLC achieved the highest tracking efficiency (99.48%) compared with PSO (80.31%) and INC (78.27%). Under temperature variations, all three algorithms exhibited relatively comparable performance, with average efficiencies of 100% for INC, 99.87% for FLC, and 97.18% for PSO. Under load variations, FLC demonstrated the most stable photovoltaic power output within the range of 350.1–350.6 W, whereas PSO produced the highest buck converter output power of 344.50 W under nominal load conditions. Based on the overall analysis, the FLC algorithm exhibited the most consistent performance among the three MPPT algorithms and is therefore recommended as the most adaptive MPPT technique for fluctuating environmental conditions.
Kata Kunci : Photovoltaic, Buck Converter, Maximum Power Point Tracking, Incremental Conductance, Fuzzy Logic Controller, Particle Swarm Optimization.