Laporkan Masalah

Penilaian Kualitas Ruang Publik Semu Vernakular di Kawasan Cagar Budaya Kotagede

Daffa Arkanantya, Ratna Eka Suminar, S.T., M.Sc.

2026 | Skripsi | PERENCANAAN WILAYAH DAN KOTA

Ruang publik semu umumnya lahir dari komersialisasi ruang perkotaan. Namun, di Kawasan Cagar Budaya (KCB) Kotagede, ruang publik semu vernakular terbentuk secara organik melalui konsensus sosial masyarakat maupun institusi berupa praktik berbagi ruang. Penelitian ini menilai kualitas 4 (empat) ruang publik semu vernakular di KCB Kotagede, yaitu halaman Masjid Gedhe Mataram, Pendopo Omah UGM, Pendhapa Kajengan, dan Gang Rukunan Between Two Gates berdasarkan aspek aksesibilitas, kenyamanan, dan vitalitas sosial. Pendekatan deduktif kualitatif digunakan dalam studi ini, didukung oleh alat bantu deskriptif berupa instrumen skala Likert dan perhitungan Simpson’s Diversity Index (SDI) dengan berprinsip kesetaraan bobot.

Kinerja kualitas keempat ruang tersebut berada pada rentang kategori "baik" hingga "sangat baik", dengan halaman Masjid Gedhe Mataram menempati peringkat tertinggi. Namun, di balik pemeringkatan agregat yang positif tersebut, analisis lebih mendalam mengungkap dua fenomena keruangan krusial. Pertama, keterbatasan infrastruktur fisik di Pendopo Omah UGM sukses dikompensasi oleh tingginya keterbukaan ruang yang memicu kesan hidden gem bagi pengunjung remaja. Kedua, keunggulan fasilitas Pendhapa Kajengan justru menciptakan demografi pengunjung yang homogen akibat privatisasi temporal oleh jadwal kegiatan komersial kelas seni budaya.

Dinamika ini membuktikan bahwa regulasi pelestarian cagar budaya memberikan keuntungan estetika sekaligus memicu hambatan fisik. Meskipun demikian, kehadiran ruang ini secara swadaya terbukti aktif menyelamatkan bangunan bersejarah dari ancaman kehilangan relevansinya. Sebagai langkah penguatan tata kelola, penelitian ini merekomendasikan intervensi kebijakan aksesibilitas dan infrastruktur penunjang oleh pemerintah daerah, penerapan zonasi waktu oleh pengelola privat demi melindungi privasi dan akses warga, serta optimalisasi kontrol sosial organik oleh masyarakat sekitar.

Quasi-public space generally arises from the commercialization of urban spaces. However, in the Kotagede Cultural Heritage Zone, vernacular quasi-public spaces have formed organically through social consensus among the community and institutions in the form of shared-space practices. This study assesses four such spaces, namely the Mataram Great Mosque Courtyard, the Omah UGM Pavilion, the Kajengan Pavilion, and the Rukunan Alley Between Two Gates, based on accessibility, comfort, and social vitality aspects. A qualitative deductive approach was used in this study, supported by descriptive tools in the form of the Likert scale instrument and the calculation of the Simpson’s Diversity Index (SDI) based on the principle of equal weighting.

The quality performance of these four spaces falls within the “good” to “very good” range, with the Mataram Great Mosque Courtyard ranked highest overall. However, beyond these positive aggregate rankings, a deeper analysis reveals two crucial spatial phenomena. First, the limitations of the physical infrastructure at Omah UGM Pavilion are successfully offset by the high degree of spatial openness, which creates a “hidden gem” impression for teenage visitors. Second, the superior facilities at Kajengan Pavilion actually result in a homogeneous visitor demographic due to the temporal privatization caused by the schedule of commercial arts and culture classes.

These dynamics demonstrate that regulations for the preservation of cultural heritage sites offer aesthetic benefits while simultaneously creating physical barriers. Nevertheless, the existence of these spaces has proven to be an effective means of safeguarding historic buildings from the threat of losing their relevance. To strengthen governance, this study recommends local government interventions in accessibility and infrastructure, time-based zoning by private managers to protect residents privacy, and optimizing organic social control by the surrounding community.

Kata Kunci : Ruang publik semu, kawasan cagar budaya, Kotagede, penilaian kualitas ruang, privatisasi temporal

  1. S1-2026-493140-abstract.pdf  
  2. S1-2026-493140-bibliography.pdf  
  3. S1-2026-493140-tableofcontent.pdf  
  4. S1-2026-493140-title.pdf