Penerimaan Masyarakat Desa AA Terhadap Program Relokasi ke BB
Dian Nurcahya, Dr. Krisdyatmiko, S.Sos., M.Si.
2026 | Tesis | S2 PEMBANGUNAN SOSIAL DAN KESEJAHTERAAN
Residential relocation in the context of development is often understood as a rational decision made by communities after objectively weighing its benefits and costs. However, this study demonstrates that the acceptance of relocation by the residents of Village AA to Settlement BB was not formed as a one-time decision but rather as a social process that evolved gradually through everyday lived experiences. Within a context that is normatively categorized as voluntary relocation, acceptance did not emerge as a completely free choice without pressure; instead, it represented an adaptive decision negotiated amid the accumulation of risks, limited living space, and transformations in the socio-economic structure of Village AA.
This study employed a qualitative approach using an intrinsic case study design to understand how acceptance of relocation was socially constructed within its specific context. The analytical framework combined Michael M. Cernea’s Impoverishment Risks and Reconstruction (IRR) Model with Amartya Sen’s Capability Approach to examine the interaction between experiences of risk, available life opportunities, and household adaptive capacities. Data were collected through in-depth interviews with relocated residents, residents who had not yet relocated, and other local actors involved in the relocation process. This approach enabled the study to capture the diversity of meanings, rationalities, and social negotiation dynamics surrounding relocation.
The findings indicate that acceptance of relocation was shaped through several key patterns: acceptance based on visual imagination of Settlement BB, more rapid acceptance among groups facing higher levels of vulnerability, acceptance as a strategy to escape pressures associated with the former environment, and acceptance without a clearly defined long-term orientation. The study also revealed several unexpected dynamics, including the role of children as a powerful moral consideration in decision-making, despite their position as objects rather than subjects within household decision-making structures. Furthermore, the research identified a phenomenon of deferred acceptance, in which residents formally accepted relocation but continued to reassess the sustainability of their livelihoods after relocation.
Within the framework of the IRR Model and the Capability Approach, acceptance of relocation can be understood as the outcome of an interaction between the accumulation of pre-relocation risk experiences and evaluations of the opportunities available in the new settlement. Acceptance does not signify the achievement of stable functionings; rather, it serves as an adaptive strategy under conditions of limited resources, constrained conversion factors, and ongoing policy uncertainty. Accordingly, this study argues that the acceptance of relocation among the residents of Village AA is a dynamic, contextual, and evolving social process that remains open to change as post-relocation experiences continue to unfold.
Kata Kunci : Relokasi, penerimaan sosial, Studi Kasus Intrinsik, IRR Model, Capability Approach