Pelindungan Hukum terhadap Benih Rekayasa Genetik (Genetically Modified Seeds): Perbandingan antara Paten dan Perlindungan Varietas Tanaman di Indonesia
Rizki Hidayat, Patent, PVP, Legal Protection, Legal Implication, GM seeds
2026 | Skripsi | ILMU HUKUM
Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui, mengkaji, membandingkan, serta
mendeskripsikan pelindungan hukum terhadap benih rekayasa genetik (GM seeds)
apabila didaftarkan melalui rezim Paten dibandingkan dengan rezim Perlindungan
Varietas Tanaman (PVT) dalam sistem hukum Indonesia. Tujuan lain dari penelitian
ini adalah untuk mendapatkan kemanfaatan dari perbandingan yang telah dilakukan
terkait implikasi hukum secara substantif dari pemilihan pelindungan GM Seeds
Metode penelitian hukum yang digunakan adalah yuridis normatif dengan
pendekatan perbandingan hukum (comparative law), khususnya menggabungkan
systematic comparative law dan substantive comparative law. Penelitian ini
merupakan penelitian deskriptif dengan pendekatan yuridis-normatif yang
menggunakan data sekunder melalui studi dokumentasi dan data primer melalui
wawancara.
Hasil penelitian menunjukan bahwa Indonesia menganut sistem kombinasi
dalam pelindungan GM seeds melalui rezim Paten dan PVT dengan pemisahan
objek hukum yang menimbulkan konsekuensi substantif berbeda, rezim Paten
berorientasi upstream dengan pelindungan pada proses mikrobiologis dan kontrol
pasar yang kuat namun minim perlindungan terhadap hak petani, sedangkan rezim
PVT berorientasi downstream dengan pelindungan langsung terhadap varietas,
keseimbangan melalui farmers’ privilege, serta integrasi aspek keamanan hayati.
Secara komparatif, PVT lebih adaptif dalam menjamin keseimbangan antara
kepentingan pemulia, petani, dan ketahanan pangan, sementara Paten unggul dalam
mendorong
inovasi teknologi, tetapi berpotensi menimbulkan ketimpangan akses. Oleh
karena itu, diperlukan penguatan regulasi melalui penambahan kewajiban aspek
keamanan dalam rezim Paten sesuai amanat TRIPs, serta pembentukan mekanisme
pengelolaan benefit sharing yang terpusat oleh DJKI dan Kementerian Pertanian
guna memastikan implementasi prinsip ABS berjalan efektif dan berkeadilan.
This research aims to identify, examine, compare, and describe the legal
protection of genetically modified seeds (GM Seeds) when registered under the
Patent regime compared to the Plant Variety Protection (PVP) regime within the
Indonesian legal system. Another objective of this research is to derive the benefits
from the comparison conducted regarding the substantive legal implications of
choosing legal protection for GM Seeds
The legal research method used is normative juridical with a comparative
law approach, particularly combining systematic comparative law and substantive
comparative law. This research is descriptive in nature with a juridical-normative
approach, utilizing secondary data through documentation studies and primary data
through interviews.
The results show that Indonesia adopts a combination system in protecting
GM seeds through the Patent and PVP regimes with a separation of legal objects
that results in different substantive consequences, where the Patent regime is
oriented upstream with protection over microbiological processes and strong market
control but minimal protection of farmers’ rights, while the PVP regime is oriented
downstream with direct protection of varieties, balance through farmers’ privilege,
and integration of biosafety aspects. Comparatively, PVP is more adaptive in
ensuring a balance between the interests of breeders, farmers, and food security,
while Patents excel in encouraging technological innovation but have the potential
to create inequality of access. Therefore, regulatory strengthening is required
through the incorporation of safety obligations within the Patent regime in
accordance with the mandate of TRIPs, as well as the establishment of a centralized
benefit-sharing management mechanism by the Directorate General of Intellectual
Property and the Ministry of Agriculture to ensure that the implementation of the
ABS principle operates effectively and equitably
Kata Kunci : Paten, PVT, Pelindungan Hukum, Implikasi hukum, GM seeds/