Balancing Consumer Autonomy and Paternalism Within Law No. 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection: Comparative Insights from the General Data Protection Regulation
Margaretha Nami Silaen, Dina W Kariodimedjo, S.H.,LL.M.,Ph.D.
2026 | Skripsi | ILMU HUKUM
The enactment of Law No. 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection (‘PDP Law’) marks Indonesia's first comprehensive data protection regime, drawing significant inspiration from the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (‘GDPR’). However, the extent to which the PDP Law balances consumer autonomy empowers data subjects to govern their own information. Meanwhile, paternalism justifies State intervention for the citizen's protection. The balancing of these two concepts in Indonesia remains underexplored. Using a normative-doctrinal methodology supplemented by a comparative approach, this research examines how both theories operate within the PDP Law in comparison with the GDPR and its leading national implementations in Ireland, the Netherlands, and France. The study finds that the GDPR achieves equilibrium through stringent consent standards, robust data subject rights, and independent Data Protection Authorities (DPAs); however, the PDP Law leans disproportionately toward paternalism due to broad State exemptions, punitive sanctions, vague definitions, and the absence of a functioning independent DPA. Drawing lessons from the three EU jurisdictions, this research recommends that Indonesia establish an autonomous and well-resourced DPA, refine statutory definitions and rights, close sectoral gaps, and pair enforcement with public education to achieve a rights-based balance between autonomy and paternalism.
Kata Kunci : Personal Data Protection, Law No. 27 of 2022, GDPR, consumer autonomy, paternalism, Data Protection Authority, comparative law, Indonesia, European Union.